Starr Hill has some pretty good beers, but Boxcar Pumpkin Porter isn't one of them. It's dark brown, the small head fades quickly. The aroma is slight. I picked up on a little malt and some spice, maybe allspice. The taste is slight, too. This thing is watery. Nothing at all up front, but in the finish there is a little bit of pumpkin and spice. And I mean a very little bit. There is just nothing going on here. But at least it doesn't taste bad.